But before investors throw their paper shares into the wastepaper bin, a closer look shows that this is not a final decline, but rather temporary turbulence.
A nasty combination of factors has hit the industry hard in 2024. At the heart of it all is the skyrocketing price of pulp, the key raw material, which is squeezing margins. A perfect storm of factors, including rising demand, supply chain disruptions and intense competition, has driven pulp prices higher.
To make matters worse, the 2024 fiscal year saw a double blow: falling paper prices and rising costs. While volume growth was not catastrophic, it lacked the robust expansion that investors were accustomed to.
Packaging: A glimmer of hope in the box
However, the growing demand for packaging, the knight in shining armor of the industry, offers a glimmer of hope. Think of Amazon and Flipkart’s delivery packages.
The booming online grocery delivery market, which is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate of 16.95%, represents a huge opportunity for carton packaging companies.
In addition, the continued demand for essential hygiene products such as tissues and toilet paper – driven by the growing population and increasing hygiene awareness – provides additional resilience.
Beyond the bottom line: A war chest full of possibilities
While headlines rhapsodize about the industry’s woes, one crucial detail often goes unnoticed – the surprisingly strong financial health of many leading paper companies. Despite operating in a capital-intensive sector, these companies sit on huge cash reserves thanks to historically high margins and past growth. And generally thanks to disciplined use of those surpluses.
This financial strength gives them a clear advantage. Unlike some of their cash-strapped competitors, these companies have the firepower to weather the crisis and invest in future growth.
The road to recovery: a bumpy ride, but not a dead end
The paper industry’s road to recovery is fraught with challenges. There remain ongoing concerns about rising costs, economic headwinds and increased competition, including cheap imports from ASEAN countries. Fears of recession in the US are further clouding the demand outlook. However, the industry is benefiting from several long-term tailwinds.
The printing press endures: Despite the rise of digital media, the Indian commercial printing market is expected to grow at a CAGR of 3% through 2032. Paper remains the medium of choice for essential print products such as books, magazines and newspapers.
The steady rise of the stationery trade: Growing consumer environmental awareness is driving demand for eco-friendly notebooks and other paper products, providing significant growth opportunities for paper companies serving this segment.
Environmentally friendly packaging: The growing environmental movement is pushing the packaging industry towards sustainable solutions. Paper companies that use environmentally friendly packaging materials can reap significant profits in the long run.
Taken together, a sector that otherwise seemed doomed can now look forward to a few healthy years. At least in terms of demand potential.
In terms of raw material prices, global pulp prices have experienced a strong upturn in recent months and are currently in the range of US$700-750 per tonne. This increase comes after a period of relative stability and is primarily due to tightening supply conditions. While new pulp capacity is expected to come online over the next few years to address immediate supply concerns, the long-term outlook points to a more balanced pulp market, with prices potentially stabilising at around US$550 per tonne.
Investing in the future: expansion strategies
Armed with ample cash and a vision for growth, leading paper companies are actively making strategic investments for the future.
Organic growth: Some companies like Andhra Paper and Seshasayee Paper are expanding their existing capacities to meet the increasing demand for packaging, a segment with significant growth potential.
Inorganic growth: Others are making strategic acquisitions, such as JK Paper’s recent acquisition of Horizon Packs and Securipax Packaging, to further consolidate their position in the lucrative packaging segment.
Important players in focus
Although the entire sector is facing headwinds, certain companies have demonstrated resilience and growth potential.
View full image
JK Paper has established itself as a prominent player in the domestic paper market. Its operating scale, coupled with superior operating margins and dominant market share in key paper segments, makes the company an industry leader. The company’s strategic focus on packaging, supported by organic expansion and strategic acquisitions, cements its position as a key beneficiary of the growing packaging market.
West Coast Paper Mills, which acquired a majority stake (72%) in Andhra Paper in 2020, and Seshasayee Paper & Boards are other companies to watch due to their diversified product portfolio and cost management strategies.
The final wrinkle: A calculated investment decision
The paper industry represents a classic investment problem – a combination of short-term headwinds and long-term potential. While the current environment may seem bleak, a closer look shows that the industry is poised for recovery.
You need to carefully weigh the risks and rewards before venturing into this sector. Before making a decision, it is crucial to understand a company’s ability to overcome challenges, its financial health and its growth strategies.
The paper industry may be struggling right now, but it could surprise with its resilience and future potential. By focusing on long-term fundamentals, readers may be able to find a hidden gem amid discounted paper stocks.
However, if pulp prices continue to rise or discipline in managing surplus weakens, this seemingly interesting long-term opportunity could prove to be a value trap at best.
View full image
Perhaps this ambiguity is why paper stocks have been on a rollercoaster ride of late. Leading players have seen price increases that have drawn attention. As expected, the rally was fueled by optimism about capacity expansion and government support. However, the initial euphoria has cooled as the industry continues to face challenges.
Only time will tell how this story continues…
Note: The purpose of this article is only to share interesting charts, data points and thought-provoking opinions. It is NOT a recommendation. If you are considering investing, you are strongly advised to consult your advisor. This article is for educational purposes only.
Manvi Agarwal has been following the equity markets for around two decades, including around eight years as a financial analyst with a value-style fund that manages money for international investors. She is currently devoted to writing about potentially ignored and/or misunderstood investment opportunities in the Indian equity markets.
Disclosure: As per SEBI guidelines, the author or his relatives may or may not own the paper shares.
Also read: From paper to digital: Raipur shows how to use blockchain for citizen services
